A mysterious Cavers court case in 1783 Selkirk

Graham Maxwell kindly sent me images of a Cavers reference he spotted in the Sheriff Court Decrees for Selkirk Sheriff Court (National Records of Scotland, SC63/6/9, page 175). The case was brought by Andrew Cairns in Burnfoot against Betty Cavers in Langtownsheel. Betty had been hired to be his servant, to be paid one pound ten shillings sterling in wages, as well as a pair of shoes and a coat. But when she was due to start service “she fell into distress”. Although she recovered she refused to work as his servant. The case report goes on at great length, but as far as I can tell the short version of the story is that the court found in Betty’s favour, and ordered Andrew Cairns to pay her expenses.

I honestly have no idea who Betty was! Firstly I’m not entirely sure where the places are. Burnfoot could be the place of that name in Hawick, but because the case was brought before the Selkirk Sheriff Court I think it’s more likely to be a place in Selkirkshire, possibly even in Selkirk itself, and likewise Langtownsheel.

Even if I look at my Cavers events database it’s hard to find likely candidate entries for Betty. For example there was a Betty Cavers christened at Hawick in 1764, and another Betty christened at Cavers in 1769. Either could be this person, especially the older one. But she could equally be someone else entirely. The parish registers do not record all births, and sometimes there are big gaps, or registers didn’t start early enough. Even looking for other variants of Betty like Elizabeth doesn’t throw up very likely candidates.

There were probably Cavers people in Selkirk at this time though. There certainly were in earlier centuries, per various Selkirk burgh court cases. And the 1841 census has quite a few elderly Cavers ladies in Selkirkshire e.g. Betty (81) and Jean (78) in Yarrow; and Isble (80), Margaret (80) and Eliza (73) in Selkirk. Could any of these be connected to the court case Betty, perhaps even Betty or Eliza?

So it’s currently a mystery. But perhaps more records will come to light in future to clarify things.

Advertisements

Two more Cavers paternity cases

I’ve blogged before (here and here) about a Cavers man defending a paternity case, where the mother of his illegitimate child went to the courts to seek financial support for the child. This was found thanks to Graham and Emma Maxwell’s index of Borders paternity cases from various sheriff courts. I now have details of two more Cavers men in trouble with the courts.

The first case is from 1878, and Duns Sheriff Court, when Mary Laing daughter of John Laing, tailor, Auchencrow, in Coldingham parish in Berwickshire went to court against William Cavers, Groom at Rumbleton, in Gordon parish, also in Berwickshire. Mary had an illegitimate male child born at Auchencrow on 25 Jan 1878, and said William was the father. I was initially puzzled about who this was, though suspected it was one of the extensive Berwickshire family of Cavers. And it probably is. He’s almost certainly William Cavers son of John Cavers and Elizabeth Aitken, who was born at Eccles, Berwickshire, on 7 Jun 1861. He married on 1 Sep 1891 at Bedshiel, Greenlaw, Berwickshire, to Margaret Renwick. At his marriage William was described as a gamekeeper. I don’t know what happened to him after this.

The second case is from 1887, again Duns Sheriff Court. This time Elizabeth Penny daughter of Alexander Penny sometime farmer at Abbey Park, Berwickshire, and later residing at Tweedmouth, and now in Canada, brought a case against John Cavers, Saddler and Ironmonger in Swinton, Berwickshire. Elizabeth had an illegitimate male child born on 2 Feb 1885, and asserted that John was the father. Looking in census returns for a possible John, the best match in 1881 was saddler John Cavers born in Eccles and living in Coldstream. He was another son of John Cavers and Elizabeth AItken, born 19 Jan 1859, and thus the above William’s older brother.

I plan to write a blog post soon about this extensive Berwickshire Cavers family, which traces back originally to Ashkirk near Hawick.

More on the Murray versus Cavers illegitimacy case

Recently I blogged about finding a previously unknown illegitimate Cavers birth. I’ve since received copies of the full case papers, which shed more light on the case.

The case was brought at Jedburgh Sheriff Court in 1832 by Elizabeth Murray against Thomas Cavers for support of the female child she apparently had with him. The papers record she was a residenter in Newcastleton, and she signed her name as Elisa Murray. Thomas was recorded as son of John Cavers, Joiner in Newcastleton, which identifies him as the son of John Cavers and Jane Douglas.

The language used in the case papers can be quite entertaining to a modern reader, but must have represented a very shocking family event. The decreet records that Thomas “prevailed upon the Pursuer [Eliza] to yield to his embraces and to admit him to a carnal connexion with her”, leading to the birth of the female illegitimate child on the 9th May 1831. Then though “the Pursuer has often desired and required the said Thomas Cavers Defender to filiate and provide for the said Child yet he refuses at least delays to do so”. She sought £1 Sterling for various expenses, and £1 10 shillings per quarter for the first 9 months from the birth for nursing fee, and £1 per quarter afterwards for aliment until the child reached the age of 10.

The next bit of the case papers includes Thomas’s responses to the charges. He declared that he was “not much acquainted with the Pursuer That she has resided for some years past with her Mother in the village of NewCastleton”. Then he says that he was in company with her on the night of Langholm Fair, in the house of Robert Elliot, but not alone with her. Various other apparently innocent meetings are admitted to, including another in the last summer or autumn when “he went into the Pursuers house along with the said Walter Oliver and there were in the house the Pursuer, her Mother and Walter Nichol Carter That this was after dark – That the Pursuer and Declarant left the rest and went round to the back of the house into a shade – That he cannot say while he was standing in the shade whether he had his arm around her Neck or Waist That he lay down in the shade with the Pursuer, but he had no carnal connection with her” And he further goes on to declare that he never had carnal connection with her, and is not the father of her child.

Thomas’s evidence is contradicted by Elspeth Elliot daughter of Robert Elliot in Newcastleton. She remembers the night of the Langholm Fair, and specifically that “the Defender came forwards and spoke to the Pursuer, after which he pushed her into the house, that after they were into the house the Defender took hold of the Pursuer and threw her into the bed, and went in beside her”.

Based on all this and other evidence the court’s judgement went in Eliza’s favour. But the case papers reveal that she believed Thomas was considering fleeing from Scotland to America “in order to defraud the Petitioner”. Thomas appeared before the court again, but denied that he had any intention of going to America “or else where out of Scotland” But the court didn’t believe him, and ordered the officers “to apprehend the said Thomas Cavers and Commit him Prisoner to the Castle of Jedburgh there to remain until he find sufficient Caution … that he shall present himself at the Sheriff Clerks Office in Jedburgh upon the fifteenth day of May next at Twelve oClock midday in order that he may be then and there accessible to the Diligence of the Petitioner against him for payment of the sums due to her as contained in the Decreet mentioned in the Petition”.

Thomas may not have settled in America, but he went to Canada, where he married and had many children. Meanwhile searching the 1841 Scottish census finds at Newcastleton 10-year old Janet Cavers living with 33-year-old Eliza Murray, 38-year-old George Murray (mealdealer), and 65-year-old widowed Janet Murray. Further research identifies these as Janet Cavers’ mother, uncle and grandmother.

Janet Cavers married at Newcastleton on 10th February 1855 to James Scott, a 28-year-old labourer. Because it was an 1855 marriage, in the first year of civil registration in Scotland, when all certificates recorded extra detail, the marriage certificate includes Janet’s birth details: she was apparently born 23rd July 1831 at Newcastleton. Her parents are named on the marriage certificate as Thomas Cavers, Labourer, and Elizabeth Cavers maiden name Murray. Obviously her parents never married, and the birth date differs slightly from the court case version, but the details otherwise fit.

James Scott and Janet Cavers had 5 children, all born at Castleton parish, probably Newcastleton:

  • Eliza, born 2 Dec 1855
  • William, b. 10 Mar 1858
  • Agnes, b. 8 Jun 1860
  • George, b. 25 Jul 1862
  • James, b. 23 Jan 1867

Janet Cavers died at Newcastleton on 25th September 1867, aged 35, cause of death typhoid fever. Again her parents are recorded on the certificate, and match the court case: father Thomas Cavers, farm servant, and mother Eliza Murray, domestic servant.

Her mother Elizabeth Murray outlived her, dying on 12th November 1894 at Newcastleton aged 84 years. Her death certificate records her occupation as domestic servant, and her parents David Murray, shepherd, and Janet Murray maiden name Murray. The informant was her son-in-law James Scott, who was present at the death. Eliza was living with her daughter and son-in-law in 1861, and the census records her birthplace as Canonbie in Dumfriesshire.

James Scott died on 16th April 1909 at Newcastleton, aged 82 years. The informant at his death was his son William. Two years later the 1911 census for 40 North Hermitage Street, where the family lived for a long time, records two of his children still living in the house: Agnes, a retired domestic servant, aged 50; and her brother George, “Farm Labourer (Cattle man)”, aged 48. Also living there then was Agnes’s daughter Nancy Scott aged 17 (Agnes was recorded as unmarried) and her granddaughter Nellie Scott aged 5. It’s quite possible that there are living descendants today of this family.

And just to add a little extra colour to the story, here are the signatures of the two parties at dispute before Jedburgh Sheriff Court, as recorded in the original case papers.

Signature of Thomas Cavers Signature of Eliza Murray

A previously unknown illegitimate Cavers birth

As genealogists research their family trees back in time it’s common to stumble across illegitimate ancestors, who were born out of wedlock, at a time when there was a great stigma attached to births outside marriage. Sometimes the child took the mother’s surname, sometimes the father’s. Sometimes the child’s father is recorded on a marriage or death certificate. In Scotland the kirk session minutes of the Church of Scotland also provide another source, because the kirk session often, especially before 1855, dragged in the mother for interrogation. But not all illegitimate births show up in these records.

A couple in southwest Scotland are currently indexing, with the help of another person, paternity cases in the Scottish Borders sheriff courts. These are cases where usually the mother sues the father for maintenance and financial support for her child. The database is growing all the time, but it already has a Cavers reference. The father was Thomas Cavers (ca1810-1879) from Newcastleton, Roxburghshire, son of John Cavers and Jane Douglas. He emigrated to Lanark County in Ontario, Canada, married twice (firstly to Margaret Lockhart, secondly to Margaret Campbell), and had at least 14 children in Canada. But now we know he had at least one more child, born before he emigrated, in Scotland.

I’m going to paste in the report from the Sheriff Court records. Unfortunately they don’t record the name of the child, just that it was a girl who was still alive when the court case was brought. She may have died in childhood, or adulthood. I will try to find out more. I suspect that the child may have used her mother’s surname, Murray, if she survived, because I don’t recall a likely Cavers candidate I’ve seen before. But I will investigate.

Jedburgh Sheriff Court Register of Decrees

(National Records of Scotland reference SC62/7/4 p48)

Decreet

Murray q Cavers

2d Apl. 1832

At Jedburgh the 10 & 31 March 1832 Sitting in Judgment John Elliot Esq Sheriff Substitute of the County of Roxburgh in an action raised before the Sheriff Court of Said County at the instance of Elizabeth Murray residenter in New Castleton Pursuer against Thomas Cavers son of John Cavers Joiner New Castleton Defender; the Sheriff found and declared and herby finds and declares the said Thomas Cavers to be the father of the said Elizabeth Murrays female illegitimate child born by her on the 9th of May 1831 and decerned and Ordained and hereby decerns and Ordains the Said Thomas Cavers Defender to make payment to the said Elizabeth Murray Pursuer of the sum of £1.0.0 Stg. of inlying Expences for said Child: Item of the sum of £1. 10/. per quarter for the first nine months from the birth of the child in name of Nursing fee: Item of the Sum of £1 per quarter thereafter in name of aliment until the Child shall have Attained the Age of 10 Years complete, the said Nursing fee and aliment to be paid quarterly and per advance: Item of the lawful int[erest] of Said Quarterly instalments from the period at wh[ich] they respectively fall due and till payment; Item of the sum of £7. 14. 10. of Expences of Pro[ces]s: Item of the farther sum of 6/ as the dues of Extracting this Decr[eet] and of recording the same And after the terms of payment are first come and by gone. Ordains &c.

More about John Cavers who died on the tramcar in New Zealand

I’ve just got details of the death certificate of John Cavers whose death I blogged about the other day. Unfortunately the parents’ details are blank on the certificate, not known. But he was thought to be born in England. I suspect that his age recorded at death was inaccurate, and that he was possibly John Cavers born at Tynemouth in 1869. If so he was the boy who was convicted of theft aged 12 in 1881, and sent onto a local training ship. This would have trained him for working in the merchant navy or similar service at sea, and the man who died in the New Zealand tramcar had occupation “Marine Fireman”. So that fits quite well with someone with that occupation who had ended up in New Zealand. I can’t prove it yet, but I’m pretty confident it’s likely to be correct now.

A chapman in 1750s Northumberland

I recently found this relatively early newspaper reference to a Cavers in Northumberland, England, not far from the Border with Scotland. It appeared in the Newcastle Courant on 9 Dec 1752.

THOMAS CAVERS, late of Hexham, Chapman

ALL Persons who are indebted unto him, are desired immediately to pay their Debts to Mr Joseph Lazenby at Hexham, who is properly authorised to receive them, otherwise, they will be proceeded against at Law, without any other Notice to recover them.

A chapman was a seller of things, typically low-cost items, often travelling from place to place to sell his wares. Many chapmen sold things like ribbons, cutlery, napkins and reading material, especially low cost books, such as chapbooks.

In this case it looks as though Thomas was trying to recover monies owing to him. I wonder where he moved on to.

At the moment I don’t know anything more about Thomas Cavers. Though he may be the same man who married Isabel Laidler at Hexham on 25 Aug 1751, according to the parish registers.

Mystery Francis Cavers and family in early 1800s Hawick

A previous blog entry outlined the descendants of James Cavers and Isabella Coltherd, including their son Francis Cavers who married Euphemia Hogg, and had a gravestone in Wilton churchyard in Hawick, Roxburghshire.

There’s a gravestone for another Francis Cavers in another Hawick churchyard, St Mary’s, but I don’t know yet where this other Francis fits in to the wider Cavers jigsaw puzzle.

1936 Hawick Archaeological Society Transactions p46
St Mary’s Churchyard, Hawick
Row XII
H.S. [Headstone]
In Memory of FRANCIS CAVERS who died on the 20th May 1811 aged __ years also of his spouse … who died 27th Decr 182_ (aged __ years also) FRANCIES CAVERS who died 8th Feby 1817 aged 11 years and 6 months.

This Francis and family are missed by Church of Scotland parish registers: no trace of a birth for Francis, or any child, or a marriage. If it wasn’t for the dates and ages given he might have been a candidate for Francis Cavers son of Francis Cavers and Euphemia Hogg christened in 1793, but the grave’s numbers would have to be extremely muddled for this to match. Alternatively he could have been an illegitimate son of Francis Cavers, born before Francis married. Certainly the only other known Cavers family using the forename Francis around this time is that of Francis Cavers husband of Euphemia Hogg. So I suspect there is probably a link to them somewhere.